PSE 20-Year Plan Hearing PACKED

PSE President and CEO, and Chair of the American Gas Association Kimberly Harris.

Likeness of PSE President and CEO, and Chair of the American Gas Association Kimberly Harris.

Wednesday, February 21st, Renton, WA at Puget Sound Energy’s 20-year Integrated Resource Plan hearing before the Utilities and Transportation Commission — More than 250 people packed the room to protest PSE’s 20-year fossil fuel plan. 100s rallied outside in the freezing cold. Public comment lasted from 1:30-4pm then started up again with King County Executive Dow Constantine at 5:30 and went until 7pm. It was incredible to witness a constant stream of people asking for a path to 100% renewable energy.

100s gathered outside of the Renton Community Center to hear speakers from Native American communities as well as Sierra Club, ReDefine Tacoma and others.

100s gathered outside of the Renton Community Center to hear speakers from Native American communities as well as Sierra Club, ReDefine Tacoma and others.

Just in!! Here’s a FANTASTIC letter that the entire 23rd Legislative District delegation (Senator Christine Rolfes, and Representatives Appleton and Hansen) sent the UTC regarding PSE’s 2017 IRP: Legislative Letter re PSE IRP to WA UTC.

Read the AMAZING letter that Bainbridge Island City Council sent to the Utilities and Transportation Commission: COBI LTR to WUTC 021518

Today, Thursday Feb 22nd, is the last day to comment on PSE’s 20-year plan:

  • Email to  Include a brief cover note that includes:
  • “This is a comment on PSE’s 2017 Integrated Resource Plan, Docket numbers UE-160918 and UG-160919”
More than 250 people packed the Renton Community Center to comment before the UTC.

More than 250 people packed the Renton Community Center to comment before the Utilities and Transportation Commission.

Groups who testified included: as 350 Seattle350 Tacoma, Backbone, Redefine Tacoma, Vashon Climate Action Group, Indigenous environmental activists, faith organizations, Puyallup Tribal Nation, Puyallup Water Warriors, Indivisible Vashon, Indivisible Bainbridge, Students for the Salish Sea, the Sierra Club. Elected officials from throughout PSE service territory testified, including King County Executive Dow Constantine, Olympia Mayor Pro-Tem Nathaniel Jones, Kirkland Deputy Mayor Jay Arnold, and Bellingham City Council Member Michael Lilliquist and Montana State Rep. Denise Hayman.

“Montana state Representative Denise Hayman attended the meeting to urge PSE to stop relying on coal.

‘I’m here to promote Montana wind,’ Hayman said. ‘We have great wind in Montana, and we could be providing that to Washington at a very reasonable cost.’

She talked about the fact that Montana wind generates the most energy in the winter, when WA needs it most and would eliminate the need for PSE’s proposed gas peaker plants.

“Puget Sound Energy declined to make anyone available to comment, but its 20-year plan indicates coal’s the cheapest option — unless Washington passes a carbon tax. That would make renewable options cheaper than coal.”

However, Governor Inslee’s watered-down Carbon Tax SB 6203 is now under attack from Montana and Wyoming.

One of the best comments I heard was from Kellen Lynch, an Energy Policy Researcher at Western Washington University:

“I am an energy policy researcher at Western Washington University and today I am here with 8 of my peers. I would like to start by thanking the UTC and Michael Lilliquist from Bellingham for coming down, as well. 
I think it is fundamentally important to remember why we are all here today. There are over 200 of us in this room. It is because we care. We care about our future. However, after listening to PSE’s presentation today I am concerned about the apparent lack of urgency in their plan. I think it’s important to look at the language that was used in their plan. Three words from their presentation today stick out to me. Those words are, “The next IRP”
Why the next? Why not now? I am worried that if we keep pushing off action we will continue to kick the can down the road as we’ve done since the 1980s when we started seriously studying climate change.

Language is important. I would like to point out that calling natural gas is disingenuous to what it really is. It would be equally accurate for me to call solar power “natural electricity” but that doesn’t tell you what it really is. Natural gas is a methane fuel. Methane is about 30 times more powerful than carbon dioxide.

Lastly, I would like to comment on PSE’s proposed small scale case study on flow batteries. I think it’s great that they are looking at batteries for energy storage. We need to go that direction. However, I am confused because PSE claims they are doing a case study because they’ve never worked with batteries before. One other thing they’ve never done before is to store massive amounts of methane fuel, like at the proposed facility near Tacoma. It strikes me as odd that they are doing a small case study for batteries, but not for a dangerous and toxic massive fuel storage infrastructure project. 

Thank you.”

King County Executive Dow Constantine testifies before the UTC.

King County Executive Dow Constantine testifies before the Utilities and Transportation Commissioners.

King County Executive Dow Constantine made a middle-of-the-road comment supporting the bills that PSE and other Investor Owned Utilities support: SB 6424 and HB 2839. (I think I was expecting more after seeing him in the movie From the Ashes.)

SB 6424 – Sponsors Carlyle, Fain, Palumbo, Saldaña
In Committee.

HB 2839 – Sponsored by Representatives Morris, Slatter, Doglio, and Fitzgibbon

House Technology & Economic Development

Bill text

Brief Summary of carbon adder bill

  • Requires electrical companies, gas companies, and the Utilities and Transportation Commission (UTC) to use a carbon planning adder when evaluating and selecting conservation policies, programs, and targets.
  • Authorizes the UTC to regulate an electrical or gas company under an alternative form of regulation.

My comment before the UTC yesterday:

After PSE’s Rate Case Hearing in August I was thrilled to learn that PSE and other stakeholders agreed to a settlement  with the UTC to move up the timeline to recover depreciation costs for Colstrip Units 3&4 to 2027.

Puget Sound Energy’s 20-year Integrated Resources Plan (IRP) makes it clear that they do not anticipate bringing any new renewable energy online in the foreseeable future without stronger environmental regulations. The plan includes continued use of fossil fuels and related infrastructure, such as:

 Gas Peaker plants, 
Tacoma’s Liquid Natural Gas (LNG) plant,
 gas from British Columbia, and
 continued operation of Colstrip.

The IRP indicates that PSE can meet the Energy Independence Act’s Renewable Portfolio Standard of 9% now and 15% starting 2020 by using Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) instead of increasing their renewable energy resources.

Washington State will not be able to meet its climate commitments without transitioning to a carbon-free future. As our state’s largest utility, Puget Sound Energy has a particular responsibility to lead the way.

Please continue to defend the public interest by rejecting any plan from Puget Sound Energy that does not move toward a 100% fossil-fuel-free future.

Thank you.

Posted in Alternative Energy, Climate, Energy | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off

Washington: Take Climate Action 7 Ways

PSE's coal-generated energy from Colstrip, MT coal plant.

PSE’s coal-generated energy from Colstrip, MT.

  1. Sign an online letter from the Sierra Club requesting renewable energy before the February 21st Energy Plan Hearing in Renton:
  2. Go to the 23rd Legislative District Town Hall Meeting on Sat. Feb 17th 10am-11:30am at Poulsbo City Hall, 200 Moe Street NE, Poulsbo. Ask for more renewable energy and a better Carbon Tax. See CarbonWA’s information on the Governor’s Carbon Tax Substitute SB 6203:
  3. Go to CarbonWA’s Climate Lobby Day in Olympia and virtually, Monday Feb 19th 8:30am-3:30pm. Information on their Facebook event page:
  4. Go to PSE’s 20-year Plan Hearing in Renton Wednesday Feb 21st noon rally, public comments start at 1:30pm. Join Sierra Club, and hundreds of concerned citizens to ask for a path to 100% renewable energy. More info: Carpool link:
  5. Listen to CarbonWA and Citizens’ Climate Lobby Wed Feb 28th 7pm discuss Climate Legislation here at Eagle Harbor Church. FB event:
  6. Go to Public Comment Meeting in Olympia March 5th to say no to offshore drilling. More info:
  7. Hike with Attorney General Bob Ferguson to Save our Coast in August. Dates to be announced. Links to FB page to follow here:


Posted in Alternative Energy, Climate, Energy | Comments Off

Join Low Carbon Girl and Hundreds of Concerned Citizens

Act now to ensure a future without fossil fuels.

Act now to ensure a future without fossil fuels.

Ask for a Path to 100% Renewable Energy

Join me and hundreds of other concerned citizens as well as groups such as, Backbone, Redefine Tacoma, Vashon Climate Action Group, Indigenous environmental activists, Puyallup Tribal Nation, Puyallup Water Warriors, Indivisible Vashon, Indivisible Bainbridge, Students for the Salish Sea, the Sierra Club and many more on February 21st – let your voice be heard. Ask for a path to 100% renewable energy now!

Public comments will start at 1:30pm. Get there by 1pm to sign in if you’d like to speak.

Let’s ask the Utilities and Transportation Commissioners to direct Puget Sound Energy (PSE) to increase their renewable energy mix to help mitigate climate change – it’s in the public’s and planet’s interest.

Puget Sound Energy’s 20-year Integrated Resource Plan recommends:

THE TIME IS NOW to influence what kind of power Puget Sound Energy will offer us in the future.

Take Action in Four Ways:

  1. Sign a letter:
  2. Write a letter from scratch to the Utilities and Transportation Commission:
    • Email to  Include a brief cover note that includes:
    • “This is a comment on PSE’s 2017 Integrated Resource Plan, Docket numbers UE-160918 and UG-160919”
    • Your organization or business name (if applicable)
    • Contact info of the person submitting the comment: Name, email, phone number, address
    • Here are some talking points: PSE IRP Hearing TPs 1.10.18
    • Please also email to The Sierra Club: and to your local community organizer:
  3. Sign a letter to PSE’s CEO Kimberly Harris requesting renewable energy:
  4. Join Low Carbon Girl and hundreds of other concerned citizens on February 21st at PSE’s Integrated Resource Plan Hearing. Location: Renton Community Center. Public comments are from 1:30pm to 7pm, please come early if you’d like to sign up to speak. If you’re interested in going to the hearing, please RSVP for the hearing at and also submit a comment!

Join me and hundreds of other concerned citizens as well as groups such as, Backbone, Indigenous environmental activists, the Sierra Club – let your voice be heard.

EXTRA POINTS: Write your legislators.

What is the Utilities and Transportation Commission (UTC)?

The Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission is a three-member commission appointed by the governor and confirmed by the state senate.

Our Mission is to protect the people of Washington by ensuring that investor-owned utility and transportation services are safe, available, reliable and fairly priced.

Regulated businesses include electric, telecommunications, natural gas, and water. The commission also regulates in-state household movers, solid waste carriers, private ferries, and inter-city busses, as well as safety issues affecting charter buses, railroads, limousines, and nonprofit senior/handicapped transportation services.

Washington State law requires that utility and transportation rates must be reasonable to customers, giving regulated companies a chance to cover legitimate costs and earn a fair profit, so it can stay in business. What is fair to the company, and at the same time fair to the people and businesses it serves, is what the commission must decide many times over. Cases are heard in a formal, legal setting, with the commission hearing evidence from all sides before issuing a decision.

* Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) Direct Links:

Posted in Climate, Energy | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off

PSE Coal-Free by 2027?

UTC_8312017Background: On August 31st, the WA Utilities and Transportation Commission (UTC)  held a hearing regarding Puget Sound Energy (General Rate Case), Dockets UE-170033 & UG-170034. It was standing room only. The Fire Marshall had to move people into the hallway to meet code. Erika from Climate Action Bainbridge and I didn’t get to speak until 8:30pm. Everyone from 6-8:30pm asked UTC to direct Puget Sound Energy (PSE) to stop using coal-generated electricity by 2025. So many eloquent speakers: Vashon Climate Action, League of Women Voters from Tacoma, Pierce and Thurston Counties, King County Council, Bellevue City Council,scientists, grad students, mayor of Olympia, from Seattle and Tacoma, Native American groups, Seattle city council, Redline Tacoma (now Redefine Tacoma), CENSE from the Eastside, and Sierra Club’s Seattle Chapter, to name a few. Over 20 pages of people signed up to speak, Erika and I were on page 6 and didn’t get to speak until 8:30pm. It’s a #revolution.

Everyone urged the commission to direct PSE to close units 3 & 4 of Colstrip and stop buying and selling coal-generated electricity by 2025. It was awe-inspiring.

Then on Sept 15th, the Sierra Club sent this email:

Today the Sierra Club, PSE, and other stakeholders in the rate case filed a settlement today with the UTC that moves up the depreciation date for Colstrip Units 3&4 to 2027 and provides $10 million dollars for transition for Colstrip, half of which comes straight out of shareholders’ pockets! The Commissioners still have to approve the settlement, but we have no reason to believe they won’t.

YOU DID THIS! Thanks to your tremendous work this summer calling PSE out for its dirty coal and gas secrets and packing rate case hearings, we just took a HUGE step towards retiring the 3rd largest source of carbon pollution in the ENTIRE United States.

The fight’s not over yet…we need to move PSE to 2025 and get a binding retirement deal. BUT WE’VE NEVER BEEN CLOSER!

Outstanding debt for Colstrip was the single biggest obstacle to retiring the plant by 2025. Not anymore!! Plus, PSE’s $10M towards transition sets a critical bar for the other owners to step up and do what’s right by the community.

I can’t tell you what an honor it is to work with each and every one of you. There have been some dark moments this year, but your passion and commitment are constant source of joy and light. THANK YOU!

Link >> to Sierra Club statement on settlement 9.15.17

Link >> LTR to PSE from House of Rep State of WA House of Representatives letter to PSE CEO Kimberly Harris asking PSE to retire the remaining two units (3&4) of Colstrip no later than 2025.

Posted in Alternative Energy, Climate, Energy | Comments Off

Ash Falling on Cedars

Fires in WA State - screen grab of Climate Central map.

Fires in WA State – screen grab of Climate Central map.

Much of the world is understandably focused on hurricanes Harvey, Irma,  Jose and Katia on the East Coast. Communities are being battered by some of the largest hurricanes ever recorded. Meanwhile, on the West Coast, where I live, there are more than 80 fires raging in Washington state.

Last year was the first time in more than 20 years of living on Bainbridge Island that I remember the sky turning white due to fires in Eastern Washington. It lasted for a day. This year it lasted for weeks. The smoke was so bad that we could no longer see Seattle from Bainbridge, we could smell smoke inside our house and outside the air stung our eyes. Fires were 90 miles away and rained ash down on our island and other parts of the state.

A local paper, the Kitsap Sun, put it best, “Kitsap residents — along with those in the wider Puget Sound region — woke to find a thin coating of ash on their cars. The sun, blood red, struggled to pierce a curtain of smoky air, turning the atmosphere an eerie yellow.”

Screen grab of New York Times article about WA fires.

Screen grab of New York Times article about WA fires.

All living things need forests. They protect the world’s water sources, and act as the lungs of the earth, taking in CO2 and exhaling oxygen.

For days we woke up to an orange sun and white sky. It felt apocalyptic. And, for me, someone who is acutely aware that the C02 from the forest fires is a horrible feedback loop. They release sequestered C02 into the atmosphere, heating up the world, drying out underbrush, making tinder for wildfires and all but ensuring more fires next year.

Clean water and air are vital to every living thing on this planet.

I know people are connecting the dots, but I think we need to continue to pull back and look at our entire earth as one biosphere, one living organism – only then can we see it is suffering from our waste byproducts (C02, plastics, removing wetland habitat, burning rainforests, green house gases, bleaching coral, polluting both water and air, etc.). Maybe then we’ll be willing to work together to reduce our impact on our life support system?

Posted in Climate, Conservation, Energy | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off

From the Ashes – Hope

From the Ashes documentaryIf you haven’t seen From the Ashes, a National Geographic documentary, it is well worth renting. Along with Al Gore’s Inconvenient Truth sequel, which our local nonprofit environmental groups (EcoAdapt, Climate Action Bainbridge, Citizens’ Climate Lobby, Island Power and Sustainable Bainbridge) brought to Bainbridge, they make a strong case for first getting off of coal, and second, getting off of fossil fuels all together.

One Biosphere
After Island Power’s campaign was tabled unanimously on June 13th by the Bainbridge City Council I started to wonder – do people just not get that coal and fossil fuels pollute both air and water – two things that are vital to every living thing on this planet? And, that we have one biosphere (earth) where everything and everyone are connected? People seem to think that we can pollute one part of the world completely forgetting that the earth doesn’t have partitions.

The idea of public power may have just been too big a concept for Bainbridge Island right now. Hopefully, a climate forum that was started in the wake of the campaign by other environmental groups on the island will provide a better opportunity to educate and discuss how we might mitigate and adapt to climate change.

Climate Leaders in Washington State
The City of Bainbridge Island council chose not to lead, even after they received a positive feasibility study, which they said would inform their decision on whether to move forward with a ballot measure. What gives me hope is that there are many organizations, businesses and local governments that see the bigger picture and are working to mitigate climate change by getting off of fossil fuels. Here are a few:

  • Microsoft: State regulators approve Microsoft move to lower its carbon footprint by acquiring clean power on wholesale markets rather than buying from PSE. Read more…
  • City of Edmonds: City Council recently approved a resolution establishing a community-wide goal of transitioning to 100 percent clean and renewable energy by 2025. Read more…
  • YES! Magazine: Our Best Shot at Meeting Paris Goals? Make Energy Public A new report finds public ownership is the best way for cities and towns to meet renewable energy and efficiency targets. Read more…
  • CarbonWA: Their initiative 732 campaign was admirable. An amazing grassroots organization that is still working toward a clean-energy economy.
  • Climate Action Bainbridge: They have worked on numerous campaigns from Sierra Club’s Beyond Coal to CarbonWA’s initiative 732. And, now CAB members Mike Cox, Gary Lagerloef, Deb Rudnick, and Lara Hansen have been chosen as members of the city’s 9-person Climate Change Advisory Committee.
  • Jefferson County: Our neighbors continue to show us what is possible. Jefferson PUD has grown from 8 to 45 employees since 2013. Read more…
  • EcoAdapt: Meeting the challenges of climate change. A nonprofit here on the island with national reach.
  • Citizens Climate Lobby: Your local chapter.
  • Sierra Club: Their Beyond Coal Campaign is now Beyond Fossil Fuels. Their campaign is featured in the new documentary From the Ashes, on the National Geographic Channel. Join them to get involved in the fight for a cleaner, healthier future.
  • The Seattle chapter.
  • Greenpeace: Climate campaigns.
  • Backbone Campaign they’re working with RedLine Tacoma and to stop the #LNG pipeline:
  • Redline Tacoma (changing their name soon) Working to stop PSE’s LNG pipeline.
Posted in Alternative Energy, Energy, My CO2 Footprint | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off

Island Power Effort Tabled for Now

From Bainbridge Island City Manager Doug Schultz’s Report June 16th, “After over two years of studying the feasibility of forming a municipal electrical utility, the City Council voted during their meeting on June 13 to cease further consideration of forming a municipal utility at this time.

City Manager Doug Schulze is featured in PSE promotion of a grant to Island Church.

City Manager Doug Schulze is featured in PSE promotion of a grant to Island Church.

We didn’t even get our measure on the ballot. As one confused person asked at the June 13th Council Meeting “how can this go forward with a 10% vote, don’t we need 51% or something?” Yes, it’s called a ballot measure. We had hoped that the council would write an ordinance to put our measure on the ballot so that the island could vote on it. But, PSE wasn’t going to make the Thurston mistake again. They were going to stop our campaign before it reached the ballot.

One concerned person wrote council:

“It was stated that there is little public support for this issue, which is no surprise seeing the constant negative press leveled by PSE using ratepayers’ dollars. Regardless if there is support now or not, it is perhaps the only meaningful way for the public to engage in dialog and debate as a democratic tool of education on this matter. The council has wisely spent the 100k of taxpayers money for the Hittle report, which lays out a positive process forward, so it seems that the public should at least have a right to a full debate and vote.”

I couldn’t agree more. People seem to like the word democracy but don’t always know what it entails.

PSE is completely embedded in our community, giving money (via their foundation) and participating in the following events (only a small sample):

  • Bainbridge in Bloom – sponsors
  • Bainbridge Farmers’ Market – booth
  • Bainbridge Museum of Art – sponsored fundraising BASH
  • Bainbridge Rotary Auction – sponsors
  • Bainbridge Chamber of Commerce – on the board
  • Bainbridge City Hall – PSE employees attend the following meetings: City Council, Utility Advisory Committee, Comprehensive Planning, and Planning Commission.
  • Bainbridge Island Downtown Association – $14,000
  • Bainbridge Schools Foundation – $5,000 grant from PSE
  • Bainbridge High School junior received a $1,000 scholarship prize from PSE for her Grand Old Fourth illustration
  • Bloedel Reserve – sponsored Light the Night event
  • City of Bainbridge Island -  received a $15,000 grant from PSE to upgrade 207 LED street lights (1/3/2017).
  • Bainbridge Island Review – digital and print ads run every week for more than 2 years. The Review came out against the idea of the feasibility study – screen grab of opinion piece sandwiched between two PSE ads.
  • Grand Old Fourth – sponsors, participants
  • Grow Development – PSE presented a rebate check of over $40,000 to support energy-efficient construction on Bainbridge Island.
  • Halloween – sponsored trick or treat downtown
  • Harbour Pub – paid for the lease on a Biodigester
  • Island Church - $50,000
  • Islandwood – sponsored 65 students
  • West Sound Wildlife Shelter – sponsored fundraising event ($10,000)
  • Chilly Hilly Bike Event – booth
  • Winter Studio Tour – sponsors


It has rained money from PSE for the past few years.  Great for the island, but, maybe not so great for democracy?


Posted in My CO2 Footprint | Comments Off

What if Earth = Garden of Eden?

The Garden of Earthly Delights by Hieronymus Bosch 1485

The Garden of Earthly Delights by Hieronymus Bosch 1485.

No matter what your religion of choice, most people have heard the story of Adam and Eve being banished from the Garden of Eden. What if all of earth is really a Garden of Eden? I was thinking about how the earth provides food, nourishment and shelter to every living thing on the planet. And, as plants and animals die they release their nutrients back into the earth to be reused. Only humans embalm their dead with chemicals, or cremate them – both of which are toxic to the earth. (Seattle started an Urban Death Project that buries people in the soil to decompose without chemicals, which is more instep with the natural world.)

And, if you’re thinking, the earth didn’t provide any shelter for humans, it did provide trees, mud, straw, stones and other naturally occurring materials, materials, which would eventually decompose and return to the earth. But, now we create cities with almost no permeable surfaces, almost no organic matter. Roads abut sidewalks which abut buildings. When rain falls instead of benefiting plants and trees, or being absorbed and filtered by earth as it moves to aquifers, streams or larger bodies of water, it runs off cement or pavement carrying oil, gas, and other toxins into waterways poisoning or killing nearshore marine life. Some cities are starting to include rain gardens to give runoff a place to enter the earth, it’s a good first step.

birdThis whole train of thought was kicked off by this image of a bird building it’s nest in a man-made structure (left) — a tree equivalent. Nature is adaptive, to a point. Plants and animals take in the world as they always have – expecting tree-like structures to be safe to make nests in, and expecting their surroundings to provide food not plastic and trash that looks like food.

Chris Jordan Midway Movie

Chris Jordan Midway Movie

That made me think of Chris Jordan’s Midway project, which should be out this year. Watch the trailer. It clearly shows what humanity is unwittingly, and probably unintentionally doing to the natural world. Midway is a North Pacific island that is a nesting place for more than ten species of birds, most notably albatross.

Leo DiCaprio tries to make sense of what we’re doing to the earth in his movie Before the Flood. He didn’t spend much time on it, but I was fascinated with the painting, The Garden of Earthly Delights (at the top of the post), which hung over his bed as a child. It was painted more than 500 years ago and depicts humans ruining the natural world.

Would we treat the earth differently if we saw it as the paradise it is instead of something to be monetized?

Posted in My CO2 Footprint | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off

Your Choice Has Power

YourChoiceHasPowerSupply and demand. The heart of our capitalist system. On one hand it’s great: our purchasing power can help to change the marketplace for the better. On the other hand: government regulations can interrupt our leverage as consumers.

The image on the left is a slightly modified Eileen Fisher ad. The original ad asks customers to buy clothes that are responsibly made and change the way business is done one purchase at a time.

Wouldn’t it be great if we had a choice of electricity providers? But, we don’t.

Electric utilities are often natural monopolies due to the expense to build and maintain the infrastructure currently used to produce and deliver electricity. Investor owned utilities (IOU), such as Puget Sound Energy (PSE), are beholden to their shareholders. IOUs are unchallenged monopolies, not held in check by normal market forces and that is why utility commissions regulate them. In Washington, the Washington Utility and Transportation Commission (UTC),  a 3-person commission, regulates approximately 8,000 utilities and carriers.

By comparison, a public utility doesn’t need to be regulated by the UTC as their ratepayers are involved and provide oversight and direction thanks to legally mandated transparency.  Public input is one big difference between public and private utilities. State laws regulate local municipal utilities through requirements for open public records, advance public notice, and public meetings.

PSE is the electricity vendor for Bainbridge Island. The city has a nonexclusive contract with them. We can’t change vendors to get off of fossil-fuel-generated electricity or become a public power utility without working with the local government. The Friends of Island Power (IP) campaign is working to educate the public about the benefits of public power and to see if the measure can get on a ballot in the future.

Currently, the island is getting a lot of attention from PSE. Their Vice President, Customer Operations and Communications has said in meetings: we hear you Bainbridge – you want greener, more reliable power.

Yes, that’s right, many islanders want greener, more reliable power. But, make no mistake about it, the only reason we have PSE’s ear is because Island Power has been running a campaign for more than two years threatening their business on Bainbridge, which is estimated at about $20,000,000 annually. PSE does not normally have town halls to answer ratepayer questions, especially not town halls led by the Vice President of Customer Operations and Communications at Puget Sound Energy.

A Benefit of Public Power
PSE’s campaign to remain our electricity provider has focused some people on the initial cost of buying the infrastructure and starting up an electric utility business on Bainbridge.  While diverting people’s attention away from the fact that the money going to PSE each year would be part of our economy on the island instead. One benefit of public power is that an increase in electric vehicles would benefit our economy if we ran our own electric utility. (Watch a video of JJ McCoy, Senior Policy Associate, NW Energy Coalition, Seattle WA talk about the Benefits to Public Power from Local Transportation Electrification.)

A Benefit of Local Control
Did your electric bill go up this winter?

High bills? PSE suggests turning your thermostat down.

High bills? PSE suggests turning your thermostat down.

While PSE suggests you make home improvements or just turn your thermostat back to keep utility bills low (see graphic), Clark’s utility’s board of commissioners approved a plan that distributes about $10 million of 2016 surplus funds back to customers.

Clark Public Utility is giving customers a one-time credit on their March bill to help ease the financial strain caused by this especially cold winter.

“Long stretches of freezing temperatures took a toll in Clark County and we saw electric usage increase dramatically,” Clark Public Utilities Board of Commissioners president Jane Van Dyke said in a news release. “Staff came to the board and suggested using a portion of 2016 surplus revenue to help customers with these high bills.”

Not every public electric utility has a surplus, but every public utility has legally mandated transparency. That means that ratepayers are part of the process – every process and have a say in how their utility is run.

Posted in Alternative Energy, Shopping | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off

PSE Island

feasiblity study, COBI, Bainbridge, public power, power, Review, Bainbridge Review, PSE, puget sound energy

PSE ads wrap around The Bainbridge Island Review. Influencing editorial? Review does not support the public power feasibility study by the Bainbridge City Council.

Welcome to Bainbridge Puget Sound Energy (PSE) Island. Its like Safeco Field or any other company-paid entity. You might not have noticed, because Madge, “you’re soaking in it.” It’s all around us like the Matrix. Oh, speaking of all around us. Look at how the PSE ads wrap around The Bainbridge Island Review like a tasty sandwich (above). And, no surprise that the editorial opinion piece about the public power feasibility study is siding with PSE: “Study Won’t Win Hearts or Minds.” So shocking! Not really. We’ve been bought.

Harbour Pub, biodigester, PSE

PSE Logo on Harbour Pub menu.

Speaking of tasty sandwiches, PSE’s logo is now on the Harbour Pub’s menu explaining how they have helped to install a biodigester at the Pub. The biodigester outputs about 90 percent fertilizer and 10 percent gas for electricity or boiling water. (PSE is paying the lease on it.)

PSE  has a full page ad in the latest issue of Park & Recreation District catalog featuring the biodigester.

PSE, free swim, swim, aquatic center, outage, sponsored swim

PSE sponsored “free” swim canceled due to a power outage – ouch!

Speaking of Parks and Rec, PSE even sponsored a FREE swim last November, when anyone could come to the pool and swim without paying the entrance fee. They had to reschedule due to a power outage. Oops.

Some days it just feels like Thurston County all over again! PSE will spend whatever it takes to buy public opinion: Under the Radar: How a Multinational Corporation Quietly Bought a County-Wide Election

Actions Speak Louder than Advertising

PSE runs ads in all the local papers: The Bainbridge Review (digial and print), the Bainbridge Islander, 98110, and the Kitsap Business Journal (back cover). They started running ads right after Friends of Island Power announced their campaign in May 2015.

Before you start thinking they’re a benevolent corporation that likes to spend its free time spreading money around our community ($14,000 to the Downtown Assoc.) in the form of BBQ giveaways, door prizes and refreshments, look where they’re really putting their money:

Their parent company as of 2007, Macquarie Bank, has fossil fuel projects that range from fracking in the UK to opencast coal mining in Australia. Its hard to imagine PSE is really a friend of the environment. However, they have gotten friendly with our community.

Smiling Faces Sometimes…

PSE employees are on the board of the Chamber of Commerce, they had an employee on the board of Sustainable Bainbridge for years. And, of course they have employees at the following meetings at City Hall: City Council, Utility Advisory Committee, Comprehensive Planning, and Planning Commission. Enmeshed, friendly, but do they have our best interests at heart? Or, do we live on a company island?




Posted in Alternative Energy, My CO2 Footprint | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments Off